Gambling Watch UK, like others, was waiting with interest to see what this report on the workings of the 2005 Gambling Act had to say about Fixed Odds Betting Terminals (FOBTs or B2 machines). For a start, the report contains a useful brief summary of how it came about that these machines are now to be found in high street betting shops (para 50, p. 18). Having been introduced on the grounds that they were not gaming machines at all, the report acknowledges that they were effectively 'taken off probation’ as a result of 'a deal' reached between DCMS, the Gaming Board and the Association of British Bookmakers, and that the limit of four machines per premises was reached as 'a trade off' between DCMS and the industry.

It is then interesting to note that the Committee clearly accepted the idea that some forms of gambling need tighter regulation than others. Although the distinction they draw between 'hard' and 'soft' gambling is probably over-simple, the implication is clear that some forms of gambling are more dangerous than others. They mention the level of stakes and prizes and the speed of play as the main distinguishing factors. The hard-soft distinction is introduced early on in the report (para 4, p.4) and is repeated a number of times (para 133, pp. 41-2; para 196, pp. 59-60). Furthermore, it is clearly recognised that Fixed Odds Betting Terminals constitute 'hard-core' gambling (para 50, p. 18), and that their presence in high street betting shops is unwelcome. To quote from the report:

The 1968 Act put in place a "regulatory pyramid", meaning that harder forms of gambling were confined to locations with tighter controls on, for example, access. The 2005 Act, as well as more recent developments, have disrupted this 'pyramid', as online gambling – much of which is not subject to UK regulation – has developed and some 'harder' forms of gambling (such as casino-style gaming machines) have been permitted in traditionally 'softer' locations (para 41, p. 15).

Despite recognising that FOBTs constitute 'hard' gambling, and recognising concern about clustering of betting shops along high streets, and acknowledging that their presence in high street betting shops is contrary to the idea of a 'regulatory pyramid', the Committee went on to make a set of extraordinary and illogical recommendations. The first of these recommendations is that the cap of four such machines per betting shop should be removed altogether (but with the proviso that if problems arise local authorities should have the right to require the removal of any machines over the minimum allowance of four). Their reasoning behind this seems to be that operators should not need to open a new outlet simply in order to increase the number of their B2 machines, but at the same time there should be no threat of reducing the numbers of these machines on the high street since there is a need 'to create certainty for operators' (para 66, p. 22). This completely fails to acknowledge that these machines are dangerous and should probably never have been allowed to be situated outside casinos in the first place.

The Committee seems more motivated to appease the industry than to protect consumers and the high street environment. But of course that is completely consistent with the Committee’s general approach which is 'to support liberalisation of rules... [while] keeping national controls to the minimum...' (para 5, p. 4). This implies that they believe the liberalisation of the last twenty years has been too little and that they would like to see more of it, a view directly at odds with that of Gambling Watch UK. Most disappointing is the complete lack in the report of a public health perspective on gambling and perhaps this is only to be expected from a Culture, Media and Sport Committee. Nowhere in the report is there any mention of a possible role for the Department of Health, something which Gambling Watch UK advocates.

But this confused and illogical treatment of B2 machines – recognising that they are examples of 'hard' gambling but refusing to deal with them accordingly – is taken still further. Having argued that 'hard' gambling should be confined to locations with tighter controls, and having listened to the arguments that FOBTs on the high street are giving great cause for concern, the report takes a further, unexpected, step in the direction of disrupting the 'regulatory pyramid' by recommending that Adult Gaming Centres (i.e. adult only amusement arcades to be found in the high streets of most towns and cities) should be allowed B2 machines on the same basis as betting shops! This is truly extraordinary and flies in the face of all the evidence the Committee received about the dangers of these machines. Their justification was that they believed Adult Gaming Centres are providing 'a controlled adult environment and have robust access controls' (para 69, p. 23).

There is some logic to one of their other recommendations about FOBTs. It seems that, because of the strange history of how these machines arrived on our high streets, the current regulations do not permit this category of machines in casinos. Hence, casinos being, according to the Committee, 'the most highly-regulated sector and... therefore the most appropriate venue for hard, high-stake forms of gaming', casinos should be permitted to operate up to 20 B2 machines with a maximum stake of £100 (para 53, pp. 19-20). Logical though that may appear to be, it would only serve to increase population exposure to what appears to be a particularly dangerous product. Furthermore, this recommendation takes on a more sinister appearance when combined with another of the Committee’s recommendations. In a section of the report devoted to casinos, the Committee heard evidence from representatives of the industry that their sector had suffered badly as a result of the 2005 Gambling Act (this is just one of the places in the report where we hear about evidence from different sectors of the industry about how badly they have been doing). In particular it was reported that there had been scarcely any developments of new casinos in the Small Casino category, due it was said to the fact that the Small Casino model was not economically viable because it allowed a maximum of only two gambling machines to every one gaming table. The committee’s recommendation, therefore, was that this ratio should be increased to 5:1, as for Large Casinos (para 169, p. 51). Were this recommendation to be acted on, and if Small Casinos were then to be economically viable, which with an allowance of 20 B2 machines it is likely that they would be, this could surely lead to an added threat to the high street in a form we have not seen before – relatively small premises (Small Casinos need be no more than 750 m² in extent), licensed as casinos but with B2 machines as the main form of gambling on offer.

The report says that the Committee was aware of and concerned about problem gambling, but the vision of gambling on our high streets which their recommendations call up – betting shops, amusement arcades and small casinos, all offering 'hard-core' gambling in the form of FOBTs – is truly alarming.

This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

Excellent analysis of disturbing findings.

That the commoittee's brief is 'to support liberalisation of rules... [while] keeping national controls to the minimum' defies words...

Steve Jones
This comment was minimized by the moderator on the site

b2s messed my whole life up from the age of 18 and now im 23 still waited away every last penny all on my high streets everyday not in my conrol

There are no comments posted here yet

Leave your comments

  1. Posting comment as a guest.
Attachments (0 / 3)
Share Your Location
Type the text presented in the image below

Latest UK News

Parliamentary group lambasts online gambling

05 Dec 2019

The All-Party Parliamentary Group for Gambling Related Harm (APPG-GRH) has produced an Interim Report into the Online Gambling Sector which does not mince...

Political parties pledge gambling reform

05 Dec 2019

All four main political parties going into the December 12th general election make specific mention of gambling in their manifestos. Congratulations to...

'The Gambling Establishment' is published - a must read

18 Sep 2019

An important new book will be out in a few days time: The Gambling Establishment: Challenging the Power of the Modern Gambling Industry and Its Allies, by Jim...

The tide is turning against the gambling industry

09 Aug 2019

Great BBC TV programme available online at from 4 July 2019. Comedian Lloyd Griffith fails to double his money during a week of gambling,...

Gambling with Lives launch shows the tide is turning

17 Nov 2018

Tuesday this week, 13th November 2018, was the launch of Gambling with Lives (GwL) at the Houses of Parliament. The event was extremely well attended by...

Gambling with Lives

16 Aug 2018

Gambling with Lives (GwL) is a new group started by the parents of a young man with a gambling addiction who committed suicide. They are naturally grief...

FOBT Stake Cut to £2 Maximum

17 May 2018

The Government has at last seen sense and done what we and so many others have been asking for. Today it has announced it is bringing the maximum stake per...

What do you think about online gambling marketing: Gambling Commission wants to know

13 Feb 2018

The Gambling Commission (GC) has announced that it is working with the Competition and Markets Authority to make sure that online gambling companies bring...

Government's disappointing consultation document regarding FOBTs

01 Dec 2017

Several months later than originally expected, DCMS – which meanwhile has become DDCMS, Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport – has produced, not...

Gambling: a big public health problem neglected

15 Sep 2017

The Gambling Commission has just published a summary of British survey findings for 2015. The results are not new but this is the first time they have put...

TV drama shows gambling machine addiction

01 Jul 2017

The problems associated with the kinds of gambling machines now to be found in betting shops throughout Britain’s towns and cities, tending to be concentrated...

Are we seeing a backlash against liberalised commercial gambling?

05 Jun 2017

I have seen a couple of signs just recently that the tide might be turning against the establishment assumption that a strong, innovating and widely...

Gambling problems are costing Government hundreds of millions

13 Jan 2017

An important report came out at the end of 2016. This was from the Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR), an influential and progressive British...

What shall we say to the Government enquiry on Fixed Odds Betting Terminals?

07 Nov 2016

Good news! Well maybe, let’s wait and see what the actual outcome is. But we do welcome the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) putting out a...

Honest admissions by prominent gambling establishment figure

11 Aug 2016

Gambling Commission’s former Chair talks at the Royal Society of Arts (RSA)   Following his five years as Chair of the Gambling Commission, Philip Graf was...

The Times highlights gambling problems

23 Mar 2016

Did you see the Times of 17th February which devoted part of its front page, a whole double-page spread and an editorial to gambling and specifically the FOBT...

British gambling policy: Business As Usual for 2016

18 Jan 2016

Are there any signs that British gambling policy is changing for the better? Two recent public meetings might suggest some cautious optimism. One was a...

Jim Orford from Gambling Watch UK talks to George Galloway

16 Feb 2015

George Galloway and his wife Gayatri wanted to know how gambling has been allowed to get so out of hand. In this interview Jim gives them an overview of how...

Labour Party's sports betting levy idea criticised

18 Aug 2014

The idea behind the Labour Party’s consultation document ‘More Sport for All’, recently announced by Harriet Harman, Labour’s Shadow Culture Secretary, is...

World Cup betting: Should we be concerned?

13 Jun 2014

The World Cup from Brazil is on and like many others I shall be keeping an eye on the television to follow the progress of England and others. When I do I...

Betknowmore UK - a new social enterprise

25 Mar 2014

Betknowmore UK is a new non-profit, social enterprise. Our mission to to develop and deliver new, innovative, support services, to tackle issues around...

Children and young people: government and industry failing to protect

16 Oct 2013

One of the better established facts, based on research carried out in several countries, is that young people are especially vulnerable to problem gambling....

Local authorities helped to control betting shops

19 Sep 2013

The main railway station in Birmingham, where I live and work, is undergoing major renovation. Its new main entrance was opened earlier this year. Directly...

The Gambling Commission fails to apply its own precautionary principle in its advice about FOBT stakes and prizes

19 Jul 2013

The Gambling Commission has written to the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport giving its advice on what should be done about maximum stakes and...

Irresponsible statement by Chair of Responsible Gambling Trust

21 Mar 2013

Gambling Watch UK has been critical of the Responsible Gambling Trust (RGT) since its launch in April 2012. For a start we think that this way of deciding how...

Gambling and Alcohol, Parallels and Shared Solutions: a New Report

21 Feb 2013

A Losing Bet? Alcohol and Gambling: Investigating Parallels and Shared Solutions, a report by Alcohol Concern and the Royal College of Psychiatrists There is...

Government fails to deal with Fixed Odds Betting Terminals on the high street but resists the Select Committee’s call to make them even more available

21 Jan 2013

On January 15th, the Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) published the Government’s response to the July 2012 CMS Select Committee’s report into...

New Gambling Research focuses on Irresponsible Players rather than Dangerous Gambling Products

05 Dec 2012

Gambling Watch UK has already been critical of the Responsible Gambling Trust (RGT) as a gambling industry-led body which disburses funds for gambling...

The gambling industry levy: £25 million would be a more appropriate target

31 Oct 2012

The industry levy: £25 million would be a more appropriate target for the annual contribution of the British gambling industry to research and treatment. The...

Social Work is Neglecting Problem Gambling

26 Oct 2012

Social Work is Neglecting Problem Gambling  It is now well established that problem gambling is linked to many individual and social problems including;...

'Hard' FOBT gambling: alarming and illogical recommendations from the Culture, Media and Sport Committee

12 Sep 2012

Gambling Watch UK, like others, was waiting with interest to see what this report on the workings of the 2005 Gambling Act had to say about Fixed Odds Betting...

Channel 4 Dispatches puts the spotlight on FOBT machines and betting shops

07 Aug 2012

The harm being done by the Fixed Odds Betting Terminals and the clustering of betting shops in poorer areas came across clearly in last night’s Channel 4...

FOBT Machine Gambling Starts to get the Publicity it Deserves

29 Jul 2012

SCHOOL kids as young as 16 are gambling illegally in high street bookies, a Sun investigation has revealed. We sent a team of 16 and 17-year-olds to a dozen...

The Expansionist Aspirations of the UK Online Gambling Industry

25 Jun 2012

I recently attended a half day seminar on The UK Online Gambling Industry. The seminar was organised by the Westminster eForum which 'aims to provide [an]...

Quaker Action on Alcohol and Drugs Welcomes Gambling Watch UK

31 May 2012

Gambling Watch is a welcome addition to the gambling landscape. The last few years have seen many changes as regards gambling: it is now widely advertised on...

Launch of the Responsible Gambling Trust

25 May 2012

April 2012 saw the launch of the new body – the Responsible Gambling Trust (RGT), which replaces the old Responsible Gambling Fund (RGF).  The RGT takes over...

The Saturday Guardian Money Section talks to leading experts

02 May 2012

Two-thirds of patients treated at the UK's first specialist problem gambling clinic have indicated that controversial fixed odds betting terminals encouraged...

High Streets First - putting the high street before betting shops

12 Apr 2012

High Streets First is campaigning for a change in the law to give local communities a say over the number of betting shops in their area. At the moment...

Support Gambling Watch UK

Together we can make a difference

We believe there is overwhelming support for the view that there are already too many opportunities for gambling and that this is bad for individual, family and community health, but our voices need to be heard if we are to influence public policy..

Click here to register your support